GitHub vs GitLab: Which Version Control Tool Is Right for You?

In software development, management of your code is of significant importance with a view of anticipating or developing an effective means of ensuring that developers do not bottleneck the workflow. Version control tools have been found to be very useful to monitor change, to track progress, and to avoid one group of developers from interfering with another group of developers working on the same code base. Nowadays version control is a hot topic, and among all the tools that help users manage it, the two most famous platforms are GitHub and GitLab. Contrary to them, both are intended for teams to handle their Git repositories, yet they include different features and operations. Here, you’ll learn how to choose the better GitHub vs GitLab for your development team in this competitive blog.

What is GitHub?

GitHub is a distributed source control system located on the cloud that helps developers in storing and collaborate with their source onions. Connecting with Git, it is a version control system (VCS), enabling users to monitor the shifts in their code over a period and deal with the cooperation on projects for programming. GitHub was started in 2008 and it has been used as one of the most widely used online repositories by developers all over the world.

GitHub offers a web application to create repositories, fetch remote files, examine codes, and even share with other developers. It is fiddler-friendly and has features such as pull requests, issue tracking and GitHub Actions for automation. GitHub has a basic plan which is free and supports small development teams, and paid plans that have extra features such as numerous private repositories, powerful collaboration tools and premium, enterprise security.

What is GitLab?

Another potent hood version control is GitLab started in 2011 and connects with Git repositories. It is an open-source tool, and it is available in cloud as well as on-premises solutions, and this means that teams have more opportunities to use this tool in our project. Like GitHub, GitLab provides a place where developers can keep their source code safe, track changes that have been made and work together on a project.

What makes GitLab different from GitHub is its emphasis put on every stage of DevOps. Currently, GitLab has integrated CI/CD pipelines to facilitate the automation of the testing, building and deployment of code. This way users of GitLab get the convenience of being able to automate and manage their development workflows right from the version control tool. Similar to GitHub, GitLab also offers its hosting services for free with added options for subscription.

Key Differences Between GitHub and GitLab

1. Deployment Options

With deployment options, there is a clear distinction in which GitHub has many while GitLab has limited options.
GitHub is an online service; your repositories are stored on GitHub’s servers. This is ideal for most users since it saves on the aspects of dealing with servers or infrastructure. However, it also has its implications – it means you have to leave your code on GitHub that you and other contributors work on, so you have to rely on their up-time and security.
GitLab offers more possibilities. Although there is a cloud-hosted solution, it is also possible to install GitLab on your own servers (self-hosted). This is particularly preferable for teams or organizations that would wish to fully control all their infrastructure and may not wish to have their data handled by third parties. The self-hosted edition of GitLab is especially appealing to the large organizations that are worried about security, privacy, or compliance.

2. Pricing Plans

In terms of tariffs, the companies have a free version with some restrictions on capabilities as well as a paid one with more opportunities.

GitHub not only provides a free plan for users, including public as well as private repositories. However, a number of integrations and features concerning CI/CD are only available on paying plans rather than the free plan. GitHub has cost-friendly paid options and it offers additional features such as enhanced identification of team members, employers’ rights to approve the members, and private repositories with no limit to the number of members.
Other platforms like GitLab have a better free plan that allows an infinite number of private repositories, and provide CI/CD directly into the tool. While GitLab offers all of the features on the free plan even if you have multiple users, the automation is especially appreciated when you don’t need to pay for the paid plan. However, features like better security, and business solutions are in paid plant but incorporating more advanced tools.

3. Features and Integrations

Although both platforms solve the basic Git needs and are functions-based, they are fundamentally different tools.
GitHub is well known to be easy to use and has a very large number of developers. It is highly compatible with a lot of third-party apps and services including Slack, Jira, Trello and so on, that is why it will suit developers perfectly. The mechanism of sharing coupled with pull requests is one of the most friendly systems for collaboration available in GitHub.
On the other hand, GitLab is much more systemic in providing a wider range of DevOps tools all within the platform. GitLab has integrated Continuous Integration and Continues Delivery pipelines, integrated issue tracking, project management tools, code review options, as well as monitoring features. The integrated CI/CD pipelines are one of the biggest advantages of GitLab and their functionality refers to the ability to test and deploy within the same platform, which saves considerable time.

4. Community and Collaboration

GitHub has the advantage here of being larger and more advanced in terms of the number of such users. Being a hub for millions of developers, open source projects, and codes and contributions, GitHub offers the best platform for developers to network and learn. Another benefit of GitHub is the Issues that allow within teams and communities, together with pull requests and boards for discussions.
However, GitLab is not as large as GitHub – and yet it is expanding, particularly, in the enterprise and the institutional segments, where the security demands are significant. GitLab can be used for those organizations who want to collaborate and have all channels required for the DevOps lifecycle without switching between different platforms; however, GitLab seems to be less popular among open-source contributors compared to GitHub.

5. Security and Permissions

As with most functions, both GitHub and GitLab contain a number of security solutions available, however, it is recognized that GitLab provides the better choices of the two.
GitHub offers very effective settings to enhance security measures such as two-factor authentication, secret scanning, and audit logs. GitHub also provides several additional features with more security, which are only available for private repositories and paid subscription such as, dependency vulnerability scanning.
Even more than that GitLab has introduced its new security features including code scanning, scanning of containers, and security to have some dashboards. Regarding security, it is also worth to note that in this case GitLab offers more precise control over its setting due to its self-hosted version which is conductive for large companies.

6. User Interface

While this is equally true for both GitHub and GitLab the latter has been cited to have a more complicated interface to use due to the general complexity common with most of Git Lab features that makes GitHub with its simple and easily understandable layout appealing to more new developers and especially those working on individual projects.
GitHub provides straight forward and smooth platform with no fancy icons or buttons. It is geared towards giving the user all necessity features without much complication. GitHub’s user interface is considered rather advantageous for its seamlessly designed code review system.
Compared to other platforms, the concept of GitLab has a complicated interface because of the presence of a vast number of connected functions. It needs a little more time to grow versus most of the other GitLab extensions, particularly to those who are unfamiliar with CI/CD or the DevOps process. However, all those functionalities are available on GitLab’s dashboard from which you can manage your code as well as test, deploy, and do almost everything under one environment.

Which One Should You Choose?

The decision between GitHub and GitLab ultimately depends on your team’s specific needs and goals.

Here are some key factors to consider:

Choose GitHub if:
- You are primarily looking for an easy-to-use platform for code collaboration.
- You want access to a large community of developers and open-source projects.
- You prefer a cloud-hosted service and don’t require self-hosting capabilities.
- Your team doesn’t need advanced DevOps tools like built-in CI/CD pipelines.
Choose GitLab if:
- You need an integrated DevOps toolset that includes CI/CD pipelines, code review, issue tracking, and more.
- You have a team that requires more control over security, particularly with self-hosted repositories.
- You need a more affordable option for private repositories and automation tools on the free tier.
- You are working on larger projects or enterprise-level applications and require more advanced features.

Conclusion

Both GitHub and GitLab offer excellent version control capabilities, but they serve slightly different needs. GitHub is perfect for developers who need a user-friendly platform for collaboration and sharing code, especially in open-source communities. GitLab, on the other hand, is an excellent choice for teams that require a more integrated DevOps environment with built-in CI/CD pipelines and a higher degree of control over security.

Ultimately, the right choice for you depends on your team’s size, needs, and workflow. If you’re a solo developer or working on smaller projects, GitHub might be the best option. However, if you need more robust DevOps tools and customization, GitLab could be the better fit.

Read More: Mobila App Development